
I’ve been lukewarm on Reds GM Wayne Krivsky. His trade of Felipe Lopez and Austin Kearns for the injured Gary Majewski and a couple of minor league arms (though Bill Bray may work out) was dubious at best, though judging from the course of the season, it didn’t hurt much.
One move that seemed harmless at the time, but may cost the team in the long run, was trading a nobody prospect for a DFA’d Kyle Lohse. This year, the Reds will pay Lohse $4.2 million for his (shitty) services this year. Yes, $4.2 million for a pitcher who has struggled to post league average numbers over his career.
The worst part, however, is yet to come:
The Reds signed Kyle Lohse to a one-year, $4.2 million deal on Tuesday, and exchanged arbitration figures with Aaron Harang. Harang and his agents asked for $5.5 million and the Reds offered $4.25.
Excuse me? The Reds are offering Aaron Harang $50,000 more than Lohse is making? Gee, Wayne, why don’t you save yourself the arbitration hearing and just give him the $5.5 million he’s requesting?
Harang has pitched well over 200 innings for the past two years, posting ERA+ figures of 116 and 128, respectively. He also demonstrated a sharp rise in strikeout rate and K/BB ratio. Simply put, Harang has demonstrated he’s a front of the rotation starter. Kyle Lohse has demonstrated that he’s a fringe starter, and will likely be relegated to full-time bullpen duty by the end of 2007. Yet, the Reds are going to try to convince a judge that Harang is worth a mere $50,000 more than Lohse.
Of course, this debacle can’t end without getting worse:
Krivsky said the team would “explore” signing Harang to a long-term deal. On Tuesday, Harang said he hadn’t heard any offers from the Reds for a long-term deal, but he’d certainly be open to staying in Cincinnati.
“In any situation a player’s going to be interested if a team is interested in locking a player up,” Harang said Tuesday from his California home. “If they want to discuss it, we definitely want to.”
Have you seen the market for starters? Is Krivsky aware that Gil Meche got $55 million? Is he also aware that Harang is a lot fuckin’ better than Meche?
Look, Harang’s agent has submitted a figure of $5.5 million for Harang’s 2007 contract, and he’ll surely win. Why not at least offer the dude $25 million over three years? That would avoid arbitration next year and buy out his first year of free agency, all at the reasonable price of $8.33 million per year. I’m not saying Harang would accept, but for a starter like him, you at least have to make the effort.